| Award | Player | Team |
| Player of the Year | Ben Roethlisberger | New York (A) |
| Front Office Bowl MVP | Ben Roethlisberger | New York (A) |
| Coach of the Year | Bill Jones | Cincinnati |
| Legend of the Game | Steve McNair | Carolina |
| Offensive Player of the Year | Ben Roethlisberger | New York (A) |
| Defensive Player of the Year | Athyba Rubin | Atlanta |
| Offensive Rookie of the Year | Ryan Mathews | New York (N) |
| Defensive Rookie of the Year | Josh Hull | Kansas City |
| All-League First Team Quarterback | Ben Roethlisberger | New York (A) |
| All-League First Team Running Back | DeAngelo Williams | Oakland |
| All-League First Team Fullback | J.D. Runnels | Chicago |
| All-League First Team Tight End | Peyton Hillis | Carolina |
| All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Steve Smith Sr. | New York (A) |
| All-League First Team Wide Receiver | Marques Colston | Denver |
| All-League First Team Center | Chris Spencer | Oakland |
| All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Willie Colon | New York (A) |
| All-League First Team Offensive Guard | Oniel Cousins | Denver |
| All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Allen Barbre | New York (A) |
| All-League First Team Offensive Tackle | Kevin Shaffer | Oakland |
| All-League First Team Punter | Brandon Fields | San Diego |
| All-League First Team Kicker | Martin Gramatica | San Francisco |
| All-League First Team Defensive End | Athyba Rubin | Atlanta |
| All-League First Team Defensive End | Darren Howard | Baltimore |
| All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Kevin Williams | Denver |
| All-League First Team Defensive Tackle | Mike Patterson | St. Louis |
| All-League First Team Inside Linebacker | Kevin Burnett | San Diego |
| All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Paul Posluszny | Cleveland |
| All-League First Team Outside Linebacker | Demarrio Williams | Green Bay |
| All-League First Team Cornerback | Glover Quin | New York (A) |
| All-League First Team Cornerback | Tim Jennings | Philadelphia |
| All-League First Team Safety | Quintin Demps | Cincinnati |
| All-League First Team Safety | Ko Simpson | Kansas City |
| All-League Second Team Quarterback | Brian Griese | Minnesota |
| All-League Second Team Running Back | Chris Johnson | Philadelphia |
| All-League Second Team Fullback | Dexter Lyon | Tampa Bay |
| All-League Second Team Tight End | Jared Cook | Miami |
| All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Stevie Johnson | Minnesota |
| All-League Second Team Wide Receiver | Sidney Rice | Baltimore |
| All-League Second Team Center | Robert Berry | Minnesota |
| All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Duane Brown | Indianapolis |
| All-League Second Team Offensive Guard | Shaun O'Hara | St. Louis |
| All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Tony Ugoh | Chicago |
| All-League Second Team Offensive Tackle | Vernon Carey | Philadelphia |
| All-League Second Team Punter | Al Oscarson | Green Bay |
| All-League Second Team Kicker | Vince Joseph | Denver |
| All-League Second Team Defensive End | Connor Barwin | Buffalo |
| All-League Second Team Defensive End | Darrell Shrophire | Cincinnati |
| All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Red Bryant | Dallas |
| All-League Second Team Defensive Tackle | Winston Howard | Detroit |
| All-League Second Team Inside Linebacker | Chad Greenway | Philadelphia |
| All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Tully Banta-Cain | Denver |
| All-League Second Team Outside Linebacker | Desmond Bishop | San Francisco |
| All-League Second Team Cornerback | Justin Miller | Cincinnati |
| All-League Second Team Cornerback | Ed Reed | St. Louis |
| All-League Second Team Safety | Charles Godfrey | Cleveland |
| All-League Second Team Safety | Chris Crocker | San Diego |
| League's Fastest Man | Demaryius Thomas | Miami |
| League's Strongest Man | Jonathan Goodwin | Tennessee |